top of page
  • Facebook Social Icon
  • Yelp Social Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Google+ Social Icon




Founded in Cuyahoga Falls, OH in 1947 McCutcheon Insurance Agency Inc. has offered comprehensive insurance options for both personal and commercial clients throughout all of Ohio including Akron, Cleveland, Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton and Toledo.


In 2014, McCutcheon Insurance merged with The Buffington Agency and relocated to our current S. Arlington Road, Akron address in an effort to provide our clients with a broader range of service and expertise.

Jenny Pillen, C.I.C.
Founder & Principal

Jenny Pillen is a second generation independent insurance agent and is co-owner of McCutcheon Insurance Agency. Jenny is a graduate of Bowling Green State University with a degree in Business. She has more than 35 years of commercial, personal and surety experience. 

Kathy Buffington
Office Manager

With more than 40 years of insurance industry and customer service experience, Kathy Buffington assists in the agency's day-to-day operations.

Jennifer Keim, C.I.C.
Founder & Principal

Jennifer Keim is a Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) and is licensed to sell insurance products throughout Ohio. As an experienced agent, her goal is to help families and business owners protect their financial freedom. Her personal goal is to become a lifetime resource for each and every client. 

Kelly Seman
Insurance Agent

A licensed Ohio Insurace Agent, Kelly Seman also brings more than 20+ years of Customer Service experience to McCutcheon Insurance helping to ensure our clients needs are always met.

bottom of page